A weird world, full of true stories · Every fact checkedSubscribe
WeirdBank

Stories · Psychology

Kitty Genovese: The 38 Witnesses Story That Was Mostly Wrong

The murder of Kitty Genovese in 1964 made the bystander effect famous, after a newspaper said 38 neighbors watched and did nothing. Here is what really happened that night, what the experiments it inspired actually found, and what newer research says about whether people help.

Who was Kitty Genovese?

Catherine Genovese, known as Kitty, was a 28-year-old woman who lived in Kew Gardens, a neighborhood in Queens, New York. She managed a bar in Queens.

Early on the morning of March 13, 1964, at about 3 a.m., she came home from work. She parked near the train station and walked toward her apartment on Austin Street. A man attacked her there. Some neighbors heard her screams. She did not survive. The man who killed her died in prison in 2016.

What did the New York Times say about the 38 witnesses?

Two weeks later, on March 27, 1964, the New York Times put her story on its front page. The headline read "37 Who Saw Murder Didn't Call the Police." The article itself said 38 people had watched the attack, and that not one of them called the police while it was happening.

That number turned a crime into a story about neighbors who chose to look away. Scientists soon wanted to know why people would behave that way.

What is the bystander effect?

The bystander effect is the idea that a person is less likely to help in an emergency when other people are around. Two psychologists in New York, John Darley and Bibb Latané, set out to test it. Their 1968 paper opens with the Genovese case and the claim of 38 witnesses.

In their best-known test, a college student sat alone in a small room and talked with other students over an intercom, a speaker system that links rooms. The other voices were tape recordings. Partway through, one voice seemed to have a seizure, a sudden fit in which a person loses control of their body. Nobody was really hurt, but the student did not know that.

When students thought they were the only one listening, 85 percent went for help before the seizure ended. When they thought one other person could hear, 62 percent did. When they thought four others could hear, only 31 percent did. Students who believed they were alone acted in under a minute on average. Those who believed four others were listening took close to three minutes.

Darley and Latané called the cause diffusion of responsibility: the feeling that someone else will act, so you do not have to. Their paper said the answer may lie more in "the bystander's response to other observers than in his indifference to the victim."

The same pair ran a second test that year. Students filled out a questionnaire while smoke poured into the room through a vent in the wall. Working alone, 75 percent reported it. In groups of three students, it was reported only 38 percent of the time. When a student sat with two actors told to ignore the smoke, only 10 percent reported it.

Did 38 people really watch Kitty Genovese die?

No. The attack was real, but the picture of 38 silent witnesses was not. There were two attacks, not three as the Times reported. The second one happened inside the back of her building, where almost nobody could see. Many people who heard the noise thought they were hearing a quarrel.

The prosecutor said only about half a dozen people saw anything useful. In 2007, the researchers Manning, Levine and Collins looked back at the case. They wrote that "there is no evidence for the presence of 38 witnesses, or that witnesses observed the murder, or that witnesses remained inactive."

In 2016, the Times itself wrote that "the portrayal of 38 witnesses as fully aware and unresponsive was erroneous."

Who helped Kitty Genovese?

During the first attack, a neighbor named Robert Mozer shouted from his window, and the attacker ran off. Others did call the police. At the time, New York had no 911 emergency number, so callers had to reach a local police station. The case is often credited with helping push for 911.

Her friend and neighbor, Sophia Farrar, ran to her and held her until help came. Kitty Genovese was still alive when the police arrived. Years later, Farrar said: "I only hope that she knew it was me, that she wasn't alone."

Kitty's younger brother, Bill Genovese, set out to learn what really happened. His search became The Witness, a documentary by director James Solomon.

Is the bystander effect real?

The lab results were real. But a lab is not a street. In a study published in the journal American Psychologist in 2020, Philpot and colleagues watched 219 real arguments and fights caught on security cameras in Amsterdam in the Netherlands, Lancaster in the UK and Cape Town in South Africa.

In about 9 out of 10 cases, at least one bystander did something to help, and usually several did. The results were similar in all three countries. Bigger crowds made it more likely, not less, that someone stepped in. The paper's title says it plainly: "intervention is the norm in public conflicts."

So which is right? We think both are, in a way. The lab tests asked whether one person, believing others were there, acts quickly. The camera study asked whether anyone in a group helps at all. It also looked at arguments and fights in city streets, not every kind of emergency.

The honest takeaway, we think, is this. The 38 witnesses story was mostly wrong. The experiments it inspired were real, but they showed something narrower than the legend. And real crowds usually help. If you see someone in trouble, do not wait for someone else. Be like the neighbor who shouted and the friend who ran to her.

Questions people ask

What really happened to Kitty Genovese?

Kitty Genovese, 28, was attacked and killed near her home in Queens, New York, on March 13, 1964. A newspaper said 38 neighbors watched and did nothing. Later research found that only a few saw part of the attack, a neighbor shouted, people called the police, and a friend held her until help came.

Is the bystander effect real?

In lab tests, people who thought others were present were slower and less likely to report an emergency. But a 2020 study of 219 real fights on security cameras found that at least one bystander stepped in about 9 times out of 10, and bigger crowds helped more often.

What is diffusion of responsibility?

It is the feeling that someone else will act, so you do not need to. Psychologists John Darley and Bibb Latané used it in 1968 to explain why people in groups were slower to help.

Sources

Every fact in this story is backed by at least two of these. How we check facts.

  1. Meredith Worthen, 'Kitty Genovese', Biography.com, first published 4 Dec 2015, updated 29 Sep 2022
  2. Darley and Latane, 'Bystander intervention in emergencies: Diffusion of responsibility', Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1968
  3. Manning, Levine and Collins, 'The Kitty Genovese murder and the social psychology of helping', American Psychologist, 2007
  4. Philpot et al., 'Would I be helped? Cross-national CCTV footage shows that intervention is the norm in public conflicts', American Psychologist, 2020
  5. Roy Peter Clark, Poynter, 2 June 2016, quoting the New York Times obituary of Winston Moseley
  6. Elizabeth Kiefer, review of The Witness, Refinery29, 10 June 2016
  7. WNYC On the Media, 'Resurrecting Kitty Genovese: A Love Story', 20 May 2016, Brooke Gladstone with director James Solomon
  8. NPR All Things Considered, interview with Kevin Cook, author of 'Kitty Genovese', 3 March 2014
  9. Jim Rasenberger, 'Nightmare on Austin Street', American Heritage 57, October 2006
  10. Charles Stangor, Principles of Social Psychology, section 9.3 'How the Social Context Influences Helping'
  11. Steve A. Nida, 'Bystander intervention and social psychology', EBSCO Research Starters
  12. Christian Jarrett, 'The truth behind the story of Kitty Genovese and the bystander effect', BPS Research Digest, 23 October 2007
  13. 'Kitty Genovese, Revised', The Wilson Quarterly
  14. Newser, 'Woman Who Comforted Kitty Genovese Dies at 92', 3 September 2020
  15. Lancaster University press release, 'Bystanders will intervene to help victims of aggressive public disputes', republished by Neuroscience News, 26 June 2019
  16. Charlotte Ruhl, 'Kitty Genovese Case Study', Simply Psychology
Video transcript

A newspaper said thirty eight neighbors watched a murder and did nothing.

That one story started a whole field of psychology, so what did scientists find when they tested it?

And why did the same newspaper admit, years later, that it got the story wrong?

The woman was Kitty Genovese. She was twenty eight, walking home from work at about three in the morning, in Queens, New York. Two weeks later, the New York Times put her story on its front page. It said thirty eight people had seen the attack, and not one had called the police.

Two psychologists in New York wanted to know why. So they built a test. A college student sat alone in a small room, talking with other students over an intercom. Then one voice on the line started having a seizure. It was only a tape recording, but the student did not know that.

When students thought they were the only one listening, eighty five percent went for help before the seizure ended. When they thought four others could hear it, only thirty one percent did. The scientists called it the bystander effect. It went into the textbooks, and the Genovese story went with it.

But the story that started it all was mostly wrong. The prosecutor said only about half a dozen people saw anything useful. One neighbor shouted from his window and scared the attacker away. Others did call the police. And her friend, Sophia Farrar, ran out and held her until help came. In twenty sixteen, the Times itself wrote that its picture of thirty eight silent witnesses was wrong.

The lab tests were real, but the streets tell a different story. Scientists later watched two hundred nineteen real fights caught on security cameras in three countries. Someone stepped in about nine times out of ten, and bigger crowds were more likely to help.

So what should you do if you see someone in trouble? We think the answer is simple: do not wait for someone else. Most of the time somebody does step in, so let it be you.

The famous story was about the people who did nothing, but the true story is about the people who acted.

More weird true stories

Psychology

Learned Helplessness Experiment: Why 6 Dogs Stopped Trying

The learned helplessness experiment is famous for dogs that lay down instead of escaping a shock they could easily get away from. It began at the University of Pennsylvania in the 1960s, where two graduate students, Martin Seligman and Steven Maier, saw it show up by accident in someone else's experiment.

November 16, 2026 · ▶ 1:58

Psychology

Dunning-Kruger Effect: The Lemon Juice Robber Who Inspired It

The Dunning-Kruger effect is the idea that being bad at a skill can also make you bad at noticing it. It began with a 1995 bank robbery near Pittsburgh, and scientists still argue over how much of it is real.

November 15, 2026 · 5 min read · ▶ 1:48

Psychology

Universe 25 Experiment: Why a Mouse Paradise Died Out

The Universe 25 experiment gave mice endless food, water and shelter, yet the colony stopped having babies and died out. Here is what scientist John Calhoun saw from 1968 to 1973, and what later research says it does and does not mean for people.

November 13, 2026 · 5 min read · ▶ 1:42

Psychology

The Batman Effect: Why Kids Dressed as Heroes Kept Working Longer

The Batman effect is the name of a real psychology study in which young children who pretended to be a hardworking character, like Batman, stuck with a boring job for longer. Here is how the experiment worked, what it found, and what it cannot tell us.

November 12, 2026 · 5 min read · ▶ 1:43