A weird world, full of true stories · Every fact checkedSubscribe
WeirdBank

Stories · Psychology

The Batman Effect: Why Kids Dressed as Heroes Kept Working Longer

The Batman effect is the name of a real psychology study in which young children who pretended to be a hardworking character, like Batman, stuck with a boring job for longer. Here is how the experiment worked, what it found, and what it cannot tell us.

What is the Batman effect?

The Batman effect is the name for a simple finding: young children kept at a boring task longer when they pretended to be a hardworking character, such as Batman. The name comes from the title of the study itself, "The 'Batman Effect': Improving Perseverance in Young Children." Perseverance means sticking with a task even when it is dull or hard.

The study was published in Child Development, a scientific journal about how children grow and learn. It appeared online in December 2016 and in print in 2017. It was led by Rachel White, a psychologist at Hamilton College.

How did the Batman effect experiment work?

The team tested 180 children from the Minneapolis area. Every child was either four or six years old.

Each child got a job that was boring on purpose. Pictures appeared on a computer screen, one after another. When a picture of cheese appeared, the child pressed the space bar. When a picture of a cat appeared, the child pressed nothing.

The researcher told each child, "This is a very important activity and it would be helpful if you worked hard on this for as long as you could." The job lasted ten minutes.

Right next to the work sat a temptation: an iPad with a fun game on it. The study's summary calls it "an extremely attractive video game." Children were allowed to stop working and play it whenever they liked. The researchers measured how much of the ten minutes each child spent working.

What were the three groups in the Batman effect study?

The children were split into three groups. Each group used a different kind of self-talk, meaning the words people say to themselves.

The first group asked themselves, "Am I working hard?"

The second group used their own name instead, as in "Is James working hard?" Talking about yourself by name is a form of self-distancing, which means thinking about yourself as if from the outside.

The third group went one step further. Each child picked a character: Batman, Bob the Builder, Rapunzel from the movie Tangled, or Dora the Explorer. They were given something to wear to match, such as Batman's cape. Then they asked about their character, as in "Is Batman working hard?"

Once every minute, a recorded voice from the computer asked each child their question again. Not every child in the third group was Batman. The paper does not say how many children picked him, and it does not report results for each character separately.

Did pretending to be Batman help kids keep working?

First, the plain truth: the iPad won. In every group, children spent more time playing the game than doing the job.

But the groups were not the same. The children pretending to be a character worked about 46 percent of the time. The children asking "Am I working hard?" worked about 29 percent of the time. The children who used their own name landed in between. The further a child stepped away from their own point of view, the longer they tended to work.

Age mattered too. Six-year-olds kept working longer than four-year-olds. Six-year-olds playing a hero worked more than half the time, against about 35 percent for six-year-olds being themselves. Four-year-olds being themselves managed about a fifth, while four-year-olds playing a hero reached about a third.

These figures are rough, because the paper shows the results as a bar chart, not as exact percentages. The authors still described the result strongly, writing that "pretending to be another character had large effects on children's perseverance."

Why does the Batman effect work?

The researchers are not sure. In the paper, they offer three possible reasons, and they write that "Further research will be needed" to tell them apart.

The first is distance. Becoming a character is a bigger step outside yourself than using your own name, and those children worked longest.

The second is the character itself. Children may copy the qualities of a hero they look up to, such as not giving up, and the costume may help them do it. White put it this way in 2017 coverage of the study: "Pretending to be strong and admirable can help a child take on those characteristics of confidence and competence."

The third is simpler: dressing up may just have made the job more fun.

What are the limits of the Batman effect study?

This was one study of 180 children from one city. Only four- and six-year-olds took part, so it shows nothing about older children, teenagers or adults. Some headlines suggested adults could try it too, but no adults were tested.

It also measured one narrow thing: how much of ten minutes a child spent on one lab task. It did not measure homework, school work or behavior at home.

The gaps between groups are also less certain than they look. On the paper's chart, the error bars (the range where the true value probably lies) overlap. A critical review by The Skeptics' Guide to Emergency Medicine, a medical podcast, pointed this out and judged that the effect was probably not clinically meaningful, meaning probably too small to make a real difference in practice.

The authors concluded that "perseverance can be taught through role play." We think the honest takeaway is smaller than that: the Batman effect is a real result from one careful study, but it has not been shown to last or to work outside a lab. Still, when a young child is stuck on something boring, asking whether their favorite hero would keep going costs nothing to try.

Questions people ask

What is the Batman effect?

The Batman effect is the finding, from a study in the journal Child Development, that young children stuck with a boring task longer when they pretended to be a hardworking character like Batman.

Who discovered the Batman effect?

A team led by psychologist Rachel White of Hamilton College. Their study appeared online in December 2016 and in print in 2017.

Does the Batman effect work on adults?

Nobody knows. The study tested only four- and six-year-old children, so it shows nothing about adults.

Sources

Every fact in this story is backed by at least two of these. How we check facts.

  1. Christian Jarrett, 'Pretending to be Batman helps kids stay on task', BPS Research Digest, 5 October 2017
  2. Hamilton College news, 10 February 2017, on the Wall Street Journal article 'Superhero Costumes Come to Parents' Rescue'
  3. Grenell et al., 'Experimental Paradigm for Measuring the Effects of Self-distancing in Young Children', Journal of Visualized Experiments, 2019
  4. White et al., 'The "Batman Effect": Improving Perseverance in Young Children', Child Development, 2017
  5. Guy Winch, 'Why Kids Should Dress as Batman When Doing Homework', Psychology Today, 5 July 2017
  6. Charles Pulliam-Moore, 'Dressing Up as Batman May Help Boost Your Productivity', Gizmodo, 5 December 2017
  7. PubMed record of White et al., Child Development, 2017
  8. Fatherly, 'Kids Who Pretend They're Batman Are Ahead Of The Perseverance Curve', 13 December 2017
  9. The Skeptics' Guide to Emergency Medicine, episode 217, 'The Batman Effect on Improving Perseverance', March 2018
Video transcript

Scientists gave kids a Batman cape and a boring job.

Right next to the job sat an iPad game. They could play it whenever they liked, so which one would win?

And what did a superhero's cape have to do with it?

This study is real. It was published in a serious child development journal, led by a psychologist named Rachel White. Her team tested one hundred eighty kids in Minneapolis, all four or six years old.

The job was dull on purpose. Pictures flashed on a computer screen. When cheese appeared, the child pressed the space bar. When a cat appeared, they did nothing. They were told it was a very important job, and it lasted ten minutes.

The kids were split into three groups. The first group was told to ask themselves, "Am I working hard?" The second group used their own name instead. The third group got to become a character. They picked Batman, Bob the Builder, Rapunzel or Dora the Explorer, and they wore something to match, like Batman's cape. They asked, "Is Batman working hard?"

Once every minute, a voice from the computer asked their question again.

Now for the part most retellings skip. The iPad won. Every group spent more time playing than working. But the kids pretending to be a hero worked about forty six percent of the time. The kids thinking about themselves worked about twenty nine percent. The six year olds playing a hero worked more than half the time. The four year olds being themselves managed about a fifth.

So why does a cape help? The researchers are not sure. It might be stepping outside yourself, copying someone who never quits, or just that the cape made it fun.

So what can a parent do with this? We think that when a kid is stuck on something boring, you should not ask whether they are working hard. Ask whether their hero would keep going. Only young children were studied, but trying it costs nothing.

The iPad still won most of the time, but becoming someone else made the kids fight back.

More weird true stories

Psychology

Learned Helplessness Experiment: Why 6 Dogs Stopped Trying

The learned helplessness experiment is famous for dogs that lay down instead of escaping a shock they could easily get away from. It began at the University of Pennsylvania in the 1960s, where two graduate students, Martin Seligman and Steven Maier, saw it show up by accident in someone else's experiment.

November 16, 2026 · ▶ 1:58

Psychology

Dunning-Kruger Effect: The Lemon Juice Robber Who Inspired It

The Dunning-Kruger effect is the idea that being bad at a skill can also make you bad at noticing it. It began with a 1995 bank robbery near Pittsburgh, and scientists still argue over how much of it is real.

November 15, 2026 · 5 min read · ▶ 1:48

Psychology

Kitty Genovese: The 38 Witnesses Story That Was Mostly Wrong

The murder of Kitty Genovese in 1964 made the bystander effect famous, after a newspaper said 38 neighbors watched and did nothing. Here is what really happened that night, what the experiments it inspired actually found, and what newer research says about whether people help.

November 14, 2026 · 5 min read · ▶ 1:45

Psychology

Universe 25 Experiment: Why a Mouse Paradise Died Out

The Universe 25 experiment gave mice endless food, water and shelter, yet the colony stopped having babies and died out. Here is what scientist John Calhoun saw from 1968 to 1973, and what later research says it does and does not mean for people.

November 13, 2026 · 5 min read · ▶ 1:42